Spaceflight Now





How does NASA train pilots to land the space shuttle?
BY STEPHEN CLARK
SPACEFLIGHT NOW

Posted: May 25, 2010


Bookmark and Share

Landing the space shuttle is the pinnacle of the piloting profession.

Commanders go to great lengths to practice for their five minutes of glory, when astronauts take over manual control of the unpowered shuttle and perform a one-shot approach and landing with a dead stick.

The shuttle closes in on the runway on a glideslope seven times steeper than a commercial airliner. Its sink rate is about 20 times higher than a typical jet during final approach, according to NASA.


Discovery glides to landing in Florida on April 20. Credit: NASA
 
Returning shuttles touch down on the runway between 225 mph and 235 mph, about 50 percent faster than most passenger jets.

That takes some getting used to, even for the most seasoned military aviators. There are no second chances and commanders have no room for error.

A complicating factor in the landing equation is the adjustment of astronauts' bodies back to gravity. Crews returning from orbit have been in weightlessness for up to two weeks.

"You're coming back and you're not adapted to the gravity field," said Air Force Col. Jim Dutton, the pilot of Discovery's most recent mission in April. "You compensate for how your body is going to feel, which we can't emulate in a simulator, by just overtraining the task to where it's absolute second nature."

Tom Marshburn, a mission specialist on an Endeavour mission last year, said returning crews can't miss the unfamiliar tug of gravity.

"It felt like a lot more than it was indicating on the meter," Marshburn said after his mission.

The manual phase of landing also comes just after a fiery hot re-entry that dazzles the senses. Pink and orange hues of plasma engulf the shuttle as it plunges back into the atmosphere traveling 25 times the speed of sound.

"The windows were full of bright pink from the plasma," Dutton said in an interview with Spaceflight Now. "And then all of a sudden, we were in a right turn. I was fortunate enough to be on the side looking out to the ground. It was over Wyoming, and there were the Rockies right there with snow-capped mountains."

Marshburn had a similar experience during re-entry over Central America.

"It's a wonderful thing to really get a feeling for the speed of the orbiter," Marshburn said after returning from a mission last summer. "You're at a very high Mach speed. You see the clouds just whipping by as you're coming over the top of them. You pass over Central America, then Cuba, then suddenly you're over Florida."

When the shuttle Atlantis glides home Wednesday, it will likely close out a quarter-century of record-setting exploration. The shuttle will have flown more than 120 million miles during 32 missions.

Navy Capt. Ken Ham, a first-time shuttle commander, will be at the controls of Atlantis during the landing, which is scheduled for 8:48 a.m. EDT at the Kennedy Space Center.

Atlantis will be prepared for a contingency rescue flight for one of the final two shuttle missions, but the storied spaceship is not scheduled to launch again.

"Hopefully, our [commander] will have a flawless landing and won't dictate that it's Atlantis' last flight," said Tony Antonelli, the shuttle's pilot. "We'll let the program managers decide if she's going to fly again."

Antonelli will be responsible for giving the commander verbal cues during the approach, lowering Atlantis' landing gear, and deploying the shuttle's drag chute.


Atlantis commander Ken Ham (left) and an instructor pilot inside a Shuttle Training Aircraft. Credit: NASA
 
Although the landing will be the first under the control of Ham, all shuttle commanders and pilots receive extensive training in ground simulators and the Shuttle Training Aircraft, or STA, a modified Gulfstream business jet designed to fly like the orbiter.

Before being certified for flight, shuttle commanders must complete 1,000 sorties in the Gulfstream jet. Pilots are required to fly 500 dives in the trainer.

Shuttle commanders say the Gulfstream STA is the best training tool in their inventory.

"The shuttle flies very nicely," said Rick Sturckow, a two-time shuttle commander. "Our simulators and our Shuttle Training Aircraft prepare us very well for this task of landing the space shuttle."

The trainers have been used by crews since the early days of the shuttle program.

Steve Nagel, a four-time shuttle flier in the 1980s and 1990s, is now an STA instructor pilot for NASA.

"It flies the same trajectory the shuttle would from 35,000 feet down to a simulated landing, and it has the same response and handling qualities as the shuttle," Nagel said. "These things have paid for themselves many times over, in my opinion, over the course of the shuttle program because it is such an authentic simulation."


STS-131 pilot Jim Dotton (left) and commander Alan Poindexter (right) after landing of Discovery in April. Credit: NASA
 
Dutton, a former pilot of F-15, F-16 and F-22 fighers, said the similarities between the STA and the real thing are striking, even in the heat of the moment during a shuttle landing.

"Our commander, Alan Poindexter, even as we were rolling in on final, he said out loud 'it flies just like the STA,'" Dutton said. "He was marveling at how much if felt just like that shuttle trainer."

Although Poindexter was in charge of Discovery's landing last month, Dutton took the stick for about 30 seconds as the 100-ton spaceplane circled over the Florida coast to line up with the shuttle runway.

"The guidance wanted a correction up, and a little bit of a roll correction, so I got to feel how it rolled and how it pitched," Dutton said. "It was very responsive, very much like a fighter, not a heavy aircraft. In terms of flying around the turn like that in an F-22 or an F-15, it felt just like it."

NASA has four modified Gulfstreams, and each aircraft features a replica of the shuttle's controls on the left side of the cockpit. The right side of the STA cockpit is set up like a conventional Gulfstream.

Engineers lower the jet's landing gear and activate its engine thrust reversers during each training dive to recreate the drag of the space shuttle orbiter.

"The visual scene is perfect because it's real," Nagel said in an interview package for NASA TV. "You fly through the real weather conditions and the real winds. By the time a commander has about 1,000 approaches in one of these airplanes, not to mention how many approaches that person has on the ground simulators...they're well prepared to land the shuttle."


Astronauts use the Shuttle Motion Simulator at the Johnson Space Center in Houston to train for malfunctions and aborts during launch and landing. Credit: Stephen Clark/Spaceflight Now
 
NASA trains shuttle pilots on the ground inside motion simulators in Houston and at the Ames Research Center in California. The simulators help prepare crews for malfunctions and aborts that could occur during launch, entry and landing.

"NASA took a multi-pronged approach to training a landing," Dutton said. "You could try and wrap everything into one simulator, but that's pretty hard."

The final planned flight of space shuttle Atlantis is symbolized in the official embroidered crew patch for STS-132. Available in our store!
U.S. SHOPPERS | WORLDWIDE


Spaceflight Now Plus
Additional coverage for subscribers:
VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 12 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: CREW'S HOME MOVIES FOR FLIGHT DAY 12 PLAY
VIDEO: COLBERT REPORT, ABC AND CLEVELAND INTERVIEWS PLAY
VIDEO: TUESDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: AMAZING VIEW OF THE MOON AND ATLANTIS PLAY
VIDEO: AEROSURFACES CHECKED OUT FOR LANDING PLAY

HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 11: GAZING DOWN AT PLANET EARTH PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 11 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: CREW'S HOME MOVIES FOR FLIGHT DAY 11 PLAY
VIDEO: STUNNING ORBITAL OVER FLORIDA PLAY
VIDEO: LEAD FLIGHT DIRECTOR CALLS THE CREW PLAY
VIDEO: UPDATE FROM MISSION MANAGEMENT TEAM PLAY
VIDEO: MONDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: PREVIEW OF FLIGHT DAY 11 ACTIVITIES PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 10 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: SUNDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: ATLANTIS FLIES UNDERNEATH THE COMPLEX PLAY
VIDEO: SHUTTLE BEGINS FLYAROUND OF THE STATION PLAY
VIDEO: ATLANTIS UNDOCKS FROM INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION PLAY
VIDEO: SHUTTLE ASTRONAUTS BID FAREWELL TO STATION CREW PLAY
VIDEO: IN-FLIGHT CREW NEWS CONFERENCE PLAY
VIDEO: NARRATED PREVIEW OF UNDOCKING AND FLYAROUND PLAY

HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 9: UPDATE ON NEW RASSVET MODULE PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 9: CELEBRATION OF ISAAC NEWTON PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 9: GOODIES AND FOOD TREATS PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 9 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: CARGO PALLET RETURNED TO ATLANTIS PLAY
VIDEO: CREW'S HOME MOVIES FOR FLIGHT DAY 9 PLAY
VIDEO: SATURDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: SATURDAY MORNING'S FLIGHT DIRECTOR INTERVIEW PLAY

HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 8: GETTING READY TO GO OUTSIDE PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 8: ASTRONAUTS WALKING IN SPACE PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 8: PIERS WORKS IN THE CUPOLA PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 8: PEEK INSIDE RASSVET MODULE PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 8 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: CREW'S HOME MOVIES FOR FLIGHT DAY 8 PLAY
VIDEO: FRIDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: LAST OF THE OLD BATTERIES STOWED AWAY PLAY
VIDEO: FINAL BATTERY INSTALLED IN THE SIX-PACK PLAY
VIDEO: SPACEWALKERS INSTALL BATTERY ECHO PLAY
VIDEO: BATTERY REPLACEMENT WORK RESUMES PLAY
VIDEO: WATCH THE ASTRONAUTS BEGIN THE SPACEWALK PLAY
VIDEO: STEP-BY-STEP WALKTHROUGH OF EVA NO. 3 PLAY
VIDEO: FRIDAY MORNING'S FLIGHT DIRECTOR INTERVIEW PLAY

HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 7: STATION'S NEWEST MODULE PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 7: GETTING READY TO WALK IN SPACE PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 7: ATLANTIS' COMMANDER AND PILOT PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 7: CHATTING WITH STATION RESIDENT PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 7 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: CREW'S HOME MOVIES FOR FLIGHT DAY 7 PLAY
VIDEO: THURSDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: ASSOCIATED PRESS, FOX AND CBS INTERVIEWS PLAY
VIDEO: THURSDAY MORNING'S FLIGHT DIRECTOR INTERVIEW PLAY

HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 6: DINNER TIME IS FUN TMIE IN SPACE PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 6: THE VICTORIOUS SPACEWALKERS PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 6: MIKE AND STEVE RETURN FROM EVA PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 6 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: CREW'S HOME MOVIES FOR FLIGHT DAY 6 PLAY
VIDEO: WEDNESDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: REMOVING GIMBAL LOCKS ON ANTENNA DISH PLAY
VIDEO: ADDING TO TORQUE TO NEW KU-BAND ATENNA PLAY
VIDEO: THE DAY'S FINAL NEW BATTERY INSTALLED PLAY
VIDEO: THIRD OLD BATTERY PULLED OUT AND STOWED PLAY
VIDEO: SECOND FRESH BATTERY PUT INTO STATION PLAY
VIDEO: FIRST OF THE NEW BATTERIES INSTALLED PLAY
VIDEO: SPACEWALKERS REMOVE FIRST OLD BATTERY PLAY
VIDEO: CABLE ON INSPECTION SENSOR UNTANGLED PLAY
VIDEO: WEDNESDAY MORNING'S FLIGHT DIRECTOR INTERVIEW PLAY
VIDEO: STEP-BY-STEP WALKTHROUGH OF EVA NO. 2 PLAY
VIDEO: PREVIEW OF FLIGHT DAY 6 ACTIVITIES PLAY

HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 5: FLIGHT DECK OF ATLANTIS PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 5: GIVING WATER TO STATION PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 5: INSIDE DESTINY LABORATORY PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 5: ROBOTICS WORKSTATION IN CUPOLA PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 5: LOOKING OUT WINDOW AT EARTH PLAY
HIGH DEFINITION TV DAY 5: DAILY SHUTTLE CHORES PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 5 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: CREW'S HOME MOVIES FOR FLIGHT DAY 5 PLAY
VIDEO: TUESDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: MSNBC AND CNN INTERVIEWS OF CREW PLAY
VIDEO: CONGRATULATIONS FROM ALL AROUND PLAY
VIDEO: RASSVET CAPTURED AND SECURED TO ZARYA MODULE! PLAY
VIDEO: TWEAKING FINAL ALIGNMENT OVER DOCKING PORT PLAY
VIDEO: DOCKING PROBE EXTENDED FROM RASSVET NOSE PLAY
VIDEO: SWINGING RASSVET FROM ATLANTIS TO STATION PLAY
VIDEO: RASSVET UNBERTHED FROM SHUTTLE BAY PLAY
VIDEO: PREVIEW OF FLIGHT DAY 5 ACTIVITIES PLAY
VIDEO: TUESDAY MORNING'S FLIGHT DIRECTOR INTERVIEW PLAY
VIDEO: ANIMATED OVERVIEW OF RUSSIA'S RASSVET MODULE PLAY
VIDEO: ANIMATED OVERVIEW OF MISSION'S CARGO CARRIER PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 4 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: MONDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: AN ADDITION TO DEXTRE ROBOT PLAY
VIDEO: TORQUING ANTENNA ASSEMBLY INTO PLACE PLAY
VIDEO: FETCHING 6-FOOT-DIAMETER ANTENNA DISH PLAY
VIDEO: BOLTING BOOM ATOP STATION'S Z1 TRUSS PLAY
VIDEO: SPACEWALKERS HANDOFF ANTENNA BOOM PLAY
VIDEO: UNPACKING ANTENNA BOOM FROM CARRIER PLAY
VIDEO: SPACEWALK NO. 1 BEGINS PLAY
VIDEO: STEP-BY-STEP WALKTHROUGH OF EVA NO. 1 PLAY
VIDEO: PREVIEW OF FLIGHT DAY 4 ACTIVITIES PLAY
VIDEO: MONDAY MORNING'S FLIGHT DIRECTOR INTERVIEW PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 3 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: MISSION MANAGEMENT TEAM CHAIRMAN UPDATE PLAY
VIDEO: CARRIER ATTACHED TO STATION'S RAILCAR PLAY
VIDEO: CARGO PALLET LIFTED FROM SHUTTLE BAY PLAY
VIDEO: SUNDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: WELCOMING CEREMONY FOR SHUTTLE CREW PLAY
VIDEO: ATLANTIS DOCKS TO INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION PLAY
VIDEO: SHUTTLE ATLANTIS PERFORMS BACKFLIP MANEUVER PLAY
VIDEO: BEAUTIFUL VIEWS OF SHUTTLE ATLANTIS APPROACHING PLAY
VIDEO: ANIMATED PREVIEW OF FLIGHT DAY 3 ACTIVITIES PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 2 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: CREW'S HOME MOVIES FOR FLIGHT DAY 2 PLAY
VIDEO: MISSION MANAGEMENT TEAM CHAIRMAN UPDATE PLAY
VIDEO: SATURDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 1 HIGHLIGHTS MOVIE PLAY
VIDEO: THE FULL STS-132 LAUNCH EXPERIENCE PLAY
VIDEO: SHUTTLE ATLANTIS BLASTS OFF! PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: GO INSIDE MISSION CONTROL DURING LAUNCH PLAY
VIDEO: POST-LAUNCH NEWS CONFERENCE PLAY

VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: VAB ROOF PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PRESS SITE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PATRICK AFB PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PAD PERIMETER PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: BEACH TRACKER PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PAD CAMERA 070 PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PAD CAMERA 071 PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PLAYALINDA BEACH PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PAD FRONT CAMERA PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: CREW ARRIVES AT LAUNCH PAD 39A PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS LEAVE CREW QUARTERS PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CREW FINISHES GETTING SUITED UP PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS WEARING TUXEDOS LAUNCH DAY PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: NARRATED REVIEW OF SHUTTLE'S PREPARATIONS PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: NARRATED REVIEW OF PAYLOADS' PREPARATIONS PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: ATLANTIS ON EVE OF FINAL PLANNED LAUNCH PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH PAD'S SERVICE TOWER RETRACTED PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: PAYLOAD BAY DOORS CLOSED FOR LAUNCH PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS INSPECT THE PAYLOAD BAY PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: JERRY ROSS' LAUNCH ON MISSION STS-61B PLAY
VIDEO: MAIDEN LAUNCH OF ATLANTIS AS SEEN LIVE IN 1985 PLAY
VIDEO: ATLANTIS' FIRST MISSION ENDS WITH LAKEBED LANDING PLAY
VIDEO: AN ASTRONAUT'S TRIBUTE TO SHUTTLE ATLANTIS PLAY

VIDEO: COUNTDOWN STATUS AND WEATHER FORECAST PLAY
VIDEO: WATCH NASA'S PRE-LAUNCH NEWS CONFERENCE PLAY
VIDEO: GET BRIEFED ON THE LAUNCH COUNTDOWN PLAY
VIDEO: HEAR FROM THE COMMANDER AT THE RUNWAY PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS ARRIVE IN FLORIDA FOR LAUNCH PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH KEN HAM PLAY
VIDEO: PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH TONY ANTONELLI PLAY
VIDEO: PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH GARRETT REISMAN PLAY
VIDEO: PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH MIKE GOOD PLAY
VIDEO: PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH STEVE BOWEN PLAY
VIDEO: PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH PIERS SELLERS PLAY

VIDEO: STS-132 MISSION PREVIEW MOVIE PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: FULL FLIGHT READINESS REVIEW NEWS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: RECAP OF THE FLIGHT READINESS REVIEW PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: MANAGERS ASSESS ISSUES BEFORE FLIGHT PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: UPDATE ON PRE-LAUNCH PREPS AT PAD 39A PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: PROGRAM BRIEFING BY SHUTTLE AND STATION CHIEFS PLAY
VIDEO: THE STS-132 MISSION OVERVIEW PRESENTATIONS PLAY
VIDEO: PREVIEW BRIEFING ON MISSION'S SPACEWALKS PLAY
VIDEO: THE ASTRONAUTS' PRE-FLIGHT NEWS BRIEFING PLAY

VIDEO: SHUTTLE EVACUATION PRACTICE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS BOARD ATLANTIS PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH DAY REHEARSAL BEGINS PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CREW BRIEFED ON EMERGENCY PROCEDURES PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: TEST-DRIVING AN EMERGENCY ARMORED TANK PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CREW'S CHAT WITH REPORTERS AT PAD 39A PLAY
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS AT KENNEDY SPACE CENTER RUNWAY PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CREW ARRIVES FOR PRACTICE COUNTDOWN PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: GANTRY PLACED AROUND ATLANTIS PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: SHUTTLE ATLANTIS REACHES PAD 39A PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CROWDS AND THE CREW CHEER ON ATLANTIS PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: OVERNIGHT ROLLOUT TO THE PAD BEGINS PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: SHUTTLE HOISTED FOR ATTACHMENT TO TANK PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CRANE ROTATES THE ORBITER VERTICALLY PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ATLANTIS RISES OFF THE TRANSPORTER PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ORBITER EMERGES FROM ITS HANGAR PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: BUTTONING UP RUDDER/SPEED BRAKE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: DOME SHIELDS AROUND MAIN ENGINES PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: EXTERNAL TANK ATTACHED TO BOOSTERS PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: PAYLOADS HEAD FOR LAUNCH PAD PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: RASSVET PLACED INTO THE TRANSPORTER PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: PALLET LOADED WITH MISSION'S CARGO PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: RUSSIAN RASSVET MODULE ON DISPLAY PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: RUSSIAN ENGINEERS DISCUSS THEIR RASSVET MODULE PLAY
VIDEO: RASSVET HATCH CLOSED FOR FLIGHT PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: FILLING MODULE WITH NASA SUPPLIES PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS VISIT THEIR SPACECRAFT PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CREW INSPECTS RASSVET MODULE PLAY | HI-DEF
SUBSCRIBE NOW



MISSION STATUS CENTER